Why Cashew Butter Has the Most Carbs Among Nut Butters

Cashew butter (FDC 170163) contains 27.57g carbohydrates per 100g — significantly more than almond butter (~18.8g), peanut butter (~20g), or tahini (~21.2g). This makes cashew butter the highest-carb common nut/seed butter. The carbs come from the cashew's naturally starchy composition — cashew nuts themselves have 30.2g carbs per 100g, the highest among all tree nuts [1].

One tablespoon (16g) delivers 94 kcal, 2.8g protein, 7.9g fat, and 4.4g carbs. Two tablespoons (32g) — a typical toast spread — totals 188 kcal, 5.6g protein, 15.8g fat, and 8.8g carbs. The carb content per serving is 50-70% higher than the same amount of peanut or almond butter [1].

Total calories at 587 kcal per 100g are the lowest among the three major nut butters: peanut butter has ~588 kcal and almond butter ~614 kcal. The lower calories come from having less fat (49.4g vs 55.5g in almond butter) — because carbohydrates contribute 4 kcal/g vs fat's 9 kcal/g [1].

Magnesium, Zinc, and Iron: Cashew Butter's Mineral Strengths

Cashew butter retains the mineral density of whole cashews in a more concentrated, spread-ready form. Magnesium: 258mg per 100g (61% DV) — two tablespoons (32g) deliver 83mg magnesium (20% DV). Whole raw cashews have 292mg per 100g, slightly higher because the butter may lose some minerals in processing [1].

Zinc: 5.16mg per 100g (47% DV) — the highest among all nut butters. Two tablespoons provide 1.65mg zinc (15% DV). Iron: 5.07mg per 100g (28% DV) — also leading among nut butters. These two minerals make cashew butter the most mineral-dense spread option for zinc and iron tracking [1].

Phosphorus: 477mg per 100g (38% DV) and potassium: 546mg per 100g (12% DV) round out the mineral profile. Copper is exceptionally high at approximately 2.2mg per 100g (244% DV) — a trait inherited directly from the whole cashew, which is one of the richest whole-food copper sources [2].

Cashew vs. Peanut vs. Almond Butter: Per-Tablespoon Comparison

Per tablespoon (16g): cashew butter: 94 kcal, 2.8g protein — peanut butter: 94 kcal, 4.0g protein — almond butter: 98 kcal, 3.4g protein. Peanut butter wins protein per serving with 43% more than cashew butter. Almond butter wins on vitamin E (3.9mg vs 0.15mg per tbsp) [1].

Carbs per tablespoon: cashew 4.4g, peanut 3.2g, almond 3.0g. Cashew butter has 38-47% more carbs per serving. For low-carb tracking, almond butter is the clear winner among the three. For ketogenic diets where every gram of carb counts, this difference accumulates over multiple servings [1].

Mineral comparison per tablespoon: cashew butter leads in zinc (0.83mg vs peanut 0.47mg vs almond 0.53mg) while almond butter leads in magnesium (45mg vs cashew 41mg vs peanut 25mg) and dominates on calcium (55mg vs cashew 7mg). Each has distinct mineral strengths [3].

Two Tablespoons on Toast: What Cashew Butter Adds

Whole wheat toast (1 slice, 28g): 69 kcal, 3.6g protein, 0.9g fat, 12.1g carbs. Adding 2 tablespoons cashew butter (32g): 257 kcal total, 9.2g protein, 16.7g fat, 21.0g carbs. The cashew butter triples the calories and quadruples the fat [1].

The sodium story varies by variant: unsalted cashew butter adds just 5mg sodium (total toast+butter: ~130mg). Salted cashew butter adds 94mg sodium (total: ~219mg). This 89mg difference per serving is the largest variable between variants for daily monitoring [1].

For a more complete breakfast, add banana slices (half banana, 60g): total 288 kcal, 9.9g protein, 16.8g fat, 33.5g carbs, 3.5g fiber. The cashew butter contributes the fat, protein, and minerals while the banana provides potassium (215mg) and natural sweetness without added sugar [1].

Saturated Fat Profile: Highest Among Major Nut Butters

Cashew butter has 9.76g saturated fat per 100g (49% DV) — the highest among the three major nut butters. Peanut butter has ~8.5g and almond butter ~4.8g. A 2-tablespoon serving contributes 3.1g saturated fat (16% DV). The higher saturated fat comes from the cashew's naturally higher stearic and palmitic acid content [1].

Monounsaturated fat dominates: 29.1g per 100g (59% of total fat) — primarily oleic acid. Polyunsaturated fat is 8.4g (17%), and the remainder is saturated. The overall profile is MUFA-dominant, similar to olive oil in fatty acid proportions if not in total amount [1].

Cholesterol is 0mg (plant-based), trans fat is 0g, and the naturally creamy texture comes entirely from the high-fat, high-starch cashew composition — no emulsifiers needed in single-ingredient cashew butter. The natural oil separation is normal; stirring reincorporates it without changing the nutritional profile [2].

Cashew Butter vs. Other Nut and Seed Butters (per 100g)

NutrientCashew ButterPeanut ButterAlmond ButterTahiniSunflower Seed Butter
Calories (kcal)587588614595617
Protein (g)17.625.121.017.017.3
Total Fat (g)49.450.455.553.855.2
Carbs (g)27.620.018.821.219.7
Magnesium (mg)25815427995328
Zinc (mg)5.162.913.294.625.28

Practical Tips for Cashew Butter

  • 1

    1 tablespoon = 94 kcal with 2.8g protein — cashew butter has the most carbs (4.4g per tbsp) among major nut butters, 38% more than almond butter [1].

  • 2

    258mg magnesium per 100g (61% DV) — two tablespoons deliver 20% of daily magnesium. Higher than peanut butter but slightly below almond butter [1].

  • 3

    5.16mg zinc per 100g (47% DV) — the highest zinc content of any nut butter. Two tablespoons provide 15% of daily zinc [1].

  • 4

    Unsalted has only 15mg sodium per 100g — salted versions jump to ~295mg. The difference adds up fast at 2 tbsp daily [1].

  • 5

    Highest saturated fat among nut butters at 9.76g per 100g (49% DV). Almond butter has roughly half (4.8g) for a lower saturated fat option [1].

Frequently Asked Questions — Cashew Butter

How many calories are in a tablespoon of cashew butter?
One tablespoon (16g) of plain cashew butter has approximately 94 calories, with 7.9g fat, 2.8g protein, and 4.4g carbs. Two tablespoons have 188 calories.
Is cashew butter higher in carbs than peanut butter?
Yes — cashew butter has 27.6g carbs per 100g vs peanut butter's ~20g. Per tablespoon, cashew butter has 4.4g carbs vs peanut butter's 3.2g — about 38% more. This comes from cashews being naturally starchier than peanuts.
Is cashew butter good for magnesium?
Yes — cashew butter provides 258mg magnesium per 100g (61% DV). Two tablespoons deliver 83mg (20% DV). Only almond butter (279mg) and sunflower seed butter (328mg) have slightly more among common nut/seed butters.
Does cashew butter have more protein than almond butter?
No — cashew butter has 17.6g protein per 100g vs almond butter's 21g. Peanut butter has the most at 25.1g. Per tablespoon: cashew 2.8g, almond 3.4g, peanut 4.0g protein.
Why does cashew butter separate?
Natural cashew butter (made only from cashews) separates because the oils rise to the top. This is normal for any single-ingredient nut butter without added emulsifiers or palm oil. Stirring before use reincorporates the oil without changing the nutritional profile.
Is cashew butter high in saturated fat?
Cashew butter has 9.76g saturated fat per 100g — the highest among major nut butters. Peanut butter has ~8.5g and almond butter ~4.8g. A 2-tablespoon serving contributes 3.1g saturated fat (16% DV). The fat is zero cholesterol as a plant-based product.

Important Notice

Nutritional values are based on USDA FoodData Central data for nuts, cashew butter, plain, without salt added (FDC 170163). Salted, roasted, honey, and raw variants are estimated from comparable USDA entries and manufacturer data. Actual values vary by brand and processing. This tool is for informational and nutrition journaling purposes only — it is not a substitute for guidance from a qualified nutrition professional.

About the Author

Manish Kumar - Author
Manish KumarNASM Certified Personal Trainer (CPT)

Certified fitness professional and nutrition researcher with over 10 years of experience in the fitness and wellness industry. Founder of Food Nutrify, dedicated to making accurate, science-backed nutrition data accessible to everyone through free, easy-to-use calculators.

NASM Certified Personal TrainerSports Nutrition Specialist

References & Sources

  1. [1] USDA FoodData Central (2024). Nuts, cashew butter, plain, without salt added (FDC 170163). U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service.
  2. [2] Aremu, M. O. et al. (2015). Proximate composition, microbial and sensory analyses of butter made from cashew kernel pieces. International Network for Natural Sciences — Inn Science Publishers.
  3. [3] Fetuga, B. L. et al. (2010). Nutritional and sensory evaluation of cashew nut butter produced from Nigeria cashew. ResearchGate — Journal of Food Technology.